Man drawing a game strategyIt’s NFL Draft Combine time again. Looks like the first pick, by the Tampa Bucs, will be quarterback Jameis Winston of Florida State. Not much doubt he deserves the honor; he’s the most NFL-ready player at the game’s most valuable position. But selecting him, and giving him the contract his position will merit, requires a team to ignore more than a few warning signs.

Fact is, Jameis Winston may be one seriously mixed up 21 year old.

Don’t take my word for it. Check out this brief summary of the evidence.

Jameis’ defenders tend to dismiss this as ‘immaturity’. No doubt that has a lot to do with it. But to a seasoned counselor, there’s another way to view it.

For one thing, these aren’t isolated incidents. They start when he’s an 18 year old freshman and continue on through his playing career. In counseling, we’re always on the lookout for patterns in problem behavior. They suggest something deeper and more persistent than youthful mistakes.

Also, Jameis doesn’t seem to learn from his experiences. He’s received an unusual amount of public criticism and exposure. It’s true that as a star player, he’s subject to scrutiny well beyond that experienced by other college students. Still, that should be seen as a major disincentive for a repeat offense. So why hasn’t all the flak motivated Jameis to be more cautious?

In our sports-mad world, the true star athlete lives in a protective cocoon. That’s in part because of the money and prestige attached to his success, not just for the kid but for the school and also for the community at large. A star player expects to be treated better than his peers– to draw the easy class schedule, to receive special tutoring, to bask in the admiration and adulation of fans. Somehow, despite this protection, Jameis is still making the front page of the newspaper. And not in a good way.

Perhaps most disturbing, Jameis Winston’s difficulties to date suggest character traits like impulsiveness,  aggressiveness, and a predilection for pointless risk-taking. Those traits are often associated with future problems with authority, including law enforcement.

So despite the obvious talent, he’s a risky pick for any team looking to get a return on their investment. If somehow it doesn’t pan out, we’ll at least have a pretty good idea what happened.

Please Comment Below


Good comment, Jeff. Thing that bothers me about Jameis is he’s so intelligent — really exceptionally so — and he comes from a stable home (his dad works for the county) so he hasn’t had the challenges some of the other athletes have faced — and yet his decision-making reflects a real oppositional streak. Kind of like Manziel last year. Of course a lot of us have oppositional traits but we’re not under the sort of scrutiny that these guys are.

Comment by Scott McMillin — March 6, 2015 @ 8:03 am

He is quite the controversy. He’s truly gifted on the field and his college coach called him the smartest player he’s ever coached. His football mentality has been compared to Peyton Manning, one of the smartest quarterbacks of all time. But off the field he is a complete mess and has been in a wide range of trouble since his college career began. It’s difficult to say why the disconnect for him occurs without a complete assessment from a trained professional. No doubt, with some outside help from the proper resources, along with a concentrated effort on his part, he might do quite well in the NFL. But it will take a lot of work and diligence. Time will tell.

Comment by Jeff — March 4, 2015 @ 1:58 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment


Subscribe to RecoverySI via Email

Join 765 other subscribers

New Content


Top Commenters

Joyce Goodale

Most Viewed

Painkillers, from Two Sides

RecoverySI on Twitter