We will have to deal with electronic smoking, which has exploded among young people even as cigarette use has declined.

Here’s an interesting article about the respective challenges faced by society in managing our chronic problems related to alcohol. The article’s point seems to be that strategies and tactics that helped reduce tobacco consumption won’t be as effective with drinking– they attribute this to the “wide social acceptance” enjoyed by alcohol . I thought that was odd, because many of the strategies used with smoking are based on ones used with alcohol.  For instance:

Strategy Smoking Drinking
1. Taxed at unusually high level Yes Yes
2. Generally permissible only in certain areas Yes Yes
3. Age-restrictions on use and purchase Yes Yes
4. Public information campaigns re health consequences Yes Yes


Two notable differences:

5. Prohibited by law while driving vehicle No Yes
6. Warnings about secondary impact on others Yes No


I doubt anyone wants to bust drivers for lighting up a Marlboro in the car.  Not what I think of as progress. Also, we do currently have nonalcoholic substitutes for wine and beer, but since they’re nonaddictive (unlike e-cigs and vaping), the comparison isn’t apt.

I am aware of a growing body of research that suggests an adverse impact of parental alcohol abuse on children, especially young children. If you’re reading this, you’re probably already familiar with the role alcohol plays in a host of medical, psychological, and social problems that have plagued society for centuries and were the original motive behind the Temperance movement. That didn’t work, but alcohol continues to do a great deal of damage to society, in a host of different ways.

Maybe we should be hearing more about that. Using data rather than emotion to make our case.

I’m not a fan of attempts to scare / shame people into changing addictive behavior. It’s been tried. I can see some advantages in increasing peoples’ awareness of the damage done, on a daily basis, to all sorts of people, all over the world.

1 Comment »

It seems to me there was more progress with this in the 80’s and 90’s , and that we’ve regressed.Possibly with the opiate scourge, alcohol is seen as a WAY lesser evil..and this may be true ..due to so many accidental overdoses and deaths due to opiates.

And because it’s seen as almost benign, I can walk into my local Target and see a display of wine before I even get my cart. At a local fancy grocery store, at checkout where you put your card in to pay, there’s a basket of miniatures..presumably to get a Nip for the Road.

Education on alcohol’s insidious and overt damage is necessary.And the beverage industry is probably more powerful than the tobacco industry! Sigh.

Comment by Lauren Carter — December 20, 2018 @ 9:27 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment


Subscribe to RecoverySI via Email

Join 981 other subscribers

New Content


Top Commenters

Joyce Goodale

Most Viewed

Painkillers, from Two Sides

RecoverySI on Twitter